Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Right. This is silly. I’m wondering: If it’s 80 years out of print, is it still protected by copyright at all?

The thing with copyright is, it seems to me: You cannot ask for them to change the rules. You just have to break them. Imagine Google had asked copyright lawyers if they could build their search engine. Crawling other peoples websites, keeping an index of their content, and then make people come to Google because “that’s where all the content is“. Would have never gotten off the ground. But now that Google exists, and even the copyright lawyers use it, it’s obvious that this is legal.

Lawyers and politicians are followers, not leaders. And much of technology is about circumventing their yesterday-values.

What did Peter Thiel say about the Internet? The world of atoms was over-regulated. So businesses fled into the world of bits. It’s a cat and mouse game. Whatever you do, better make sure you’re the cat.



Worth noting that Google tried (and failed) to solve this specific problem

https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/04/the-t...


> The thing with copyright is, it seems to me: You cannot ask for them to change the rules. You just have to break them.

Absolutely. Break them and support the people who facilitate the disobedience. Fuck the copyright lobby, fuck publishers, and fuck anyone who gets in the way of me reading what I want in whatever form I want.

The people who are preventing you from reading what you want in the form you want it are not protecting some sacred system of authorship reward. They have no ethos. They are simply protecting the interest of their masters, for pay.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: